Antibiotics and IBS: Complex Relationship

Patients often get frustrated by doctors worrying about prescribing antibiotics. One of many reasons why doctors think twice before prescribing antibiotics is that the connection between antibiotic use and Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) has emerged as a topic of growing interest. A large-scale case–control study involving 29,111 IBS patients and 135,172 controls offers new insights into this association.

The Study: A Deeper Dive into Antibiotics and IBS

Led by Staller et al. (2023), this study marks a significant step in understanding the potential link between antibiotic exposure and the later development of IBS. The researchers meticulously analysed data, focusing on antibiotic use more than a year before an IBS diagnosis.

Key Findings: A Dose-Response Relationship

  • Increased IBS Risk with Antibiotic Use: The study found a significant association between any history of antibiotic exposure and a later diagnosis of IBS.
  • The More Antibiotics, the Higher the Risk: Notably, there was a dose–response relationship. Individuals with three or more historical antibiotic prescriptions faced a 2.36 to 3.36 times higher risk of being diagnosed with IBS.

Tetracyclines: A Notable Culprit

While all antibiotic classes were linked to IBS development, tetracyclines showed the highest association, hinting at a class-specific impact on gut health.

Other Factors in the IBS Puzzle

  • GI Infection History: Interestingly, a personal history of GI infection up to a year prior to IBS diagnosis didn’t significantly change the odds of developing IBS.
  • The Role of Acute GI Infection: Acute GI infection could be the initial trigger, with antibiotic exposure providing a second hit that disrupts the microbiome and potentially leads to IBS.

A Closer Look at the IBS Subtypes

The high proportion of IBS with diarrhoea (57.7%) in this study does raise some questions about potential biases in the methodology, such as the selection of cases undergoing colonoscopy and biopsy.

Psychological Factors and Healthcare Seeking Behaviour

The absence of data on psychiatric illnesses and antidepressant medication use in this population is a gap, given the known association of mental health conditions with IBS. Additionally, the higher number of outpatient visits in the IBS group suggests that healthcare-seeking behaviour might influence the likelihood of receiving antibiotics.

Broader Implications and Future Directions

The increasing global misuse of antibiotics, coupled with the complexity of the gut microbiome influenced by diet, medications, and genetics, underscores the need for further research. Key questions remain: What specific changes in the microbiome lead to IBS? And can interventions like prebiotics, probiotics, or dietary changes offer protection?

My Perspective

One takeaway is clear: limiting unnecessary antibiotic prescriptions should be a top public health priority. Understanding and addressing the nuances of antibiotic use and its impact on gut health is crucial to improving gastrointestinal well-being.

To a healthier gut and a wiser approach to antibiotics.

Please help someone else by sharing this blog. 

Dr. J. Hugh Coyne

Coyne Medical

Antibiotics IBS